Skip to content

Perspectives on Perfect World’s Cryptic Acquisition (Or It’s Alright to be Wrong, Part Two)

June 1, 2011

Most everyone in the MMO gaming and blogging community has probably heard of the acquisition of Cryptic studios by Perfect World. It was nice to know, thanks to Mr. Jennings of Broken Toys, that Cryptic was bought by Perfect World for almost double the base price that Atari paid for the company.

In reference to my previous post about my blogging habits and about how it’s okay to be wrong, assume we have at least two different viewpoints. On the one hand, we can have a viewpoint where the acquisition can be seen as a “complete mess”, made potentially worse by the fact that a predominantly F2P MMO developer bought the game company(inaccurate wording, but give me a break) for double the price. On the other hand, we have the the generally positive, cautiously optimistic viewpoint that this can be good in the short term for both companies (from a PR and development standpoint), but cannot be accurately predicted in the long-term.

I have no qualms with either viewpoint, and will generally leave my personal bias out of this discussion. Both sides have some good points and bad points, and though the research on the cautiously optimistic viewpoint is more pronounced, acknowledging the possibility of catastrophic failure on the part of Cryptic is something that should be considered and thought, since acknowledging a potential unsavory future for the company and the history of gaming leads us to try and steer clear of it.

With the naysayers in this case, I think the issue of relevance may be a factor in how their perception has come to see this situation. Some of them may have come from an earlier point in time in STO’s lifecycle, and thus have not experienced changes made to the game. Worse still, there’s no pertinent information in the above linked blog post to conclude that Cryptic games will “nosedive” after this acquisition.

As for the cautiously optimistic… well, for lack of a better way of putting it, you can’t be full-blown optimistic about this one, so a measured dose of skepticism may be needed given Cryptic’s track record. So long as people support Cryptic in the future though, and Perfect World can infuse the game with renewed vigor that adds onto the changes Cryptic has made to its games, then it should be good.

As for me, the best part of this is the possibility that curious members of the gaming community will try other Perfect World games, realize it isn’t as bad as it seems, and partake of Perfect World’s offerings outside of Cryptic games and the Torchlight MMO.

Better still, Perfect World now has two companies that have a deep knowledge of how to offer player-created content to the public. If Cryptic and Runic Games can be convinced to share resources and information with Perfect World, it would be an amazing bit of gaming to realize a F2P fantasy MMO with player-created content set in a completely original world. F2P MMOs would no longer be constrained by the stigma of grinding, but instead be connected to player-made content, and that would be awesome.

That said, I have to once again look up at the infinite vastness of space, consider the immeasurable number of possibilities, and say to myself, “Gee, I don’t know. I could be wrong.

Of course, Being wrong never stopped a man from hoping though. 🙂

11 Comments leave one →
  1. June 1, 2011 09:54

    You’ve made me think of something: wouldn’t Neverwinter and Torchlight be competing titles? Makes me think that perhaps Neverwinter won’t see the light of day in that case.

    • June 1, 2011 09:57

      Not necessarily. We’ve yet to know how Neverwinter will really work when compared to the also in-development Torchlight MMO, and just how much of a similarity the questing and combat systems of the two will have.

      Worst case scenario is that Cryptic doesn’t actually get to release Neverwinter at all if the property owners for that game world do not like the new owners of Cryptic. Hopefully, that won’t be the case though.

  2. June 1, 2011 10:30

    We don’t really know how the Torchlight MMO will work, other than they’ve said there won’t be a subscription. Will it still be the top-down Diablo-esque camera angle of Torchlight?

    Also, Neverwinter isn’t an MMO — it’s a 5-player online co-op RPG. I’ve assumed since it was announced that it would also be F2P, though Cryptic hasn’t announced that (or much of anything else) about Neverwinter yet, though it’s probably safe to assume that it will be the standard 3rd-person, 3D world we see in Cryptic’s MMOs. The engine specializes in character detail so it wouldn’t make sense to throw us into some odd top-down camera.

    • June 1, 2011 10:33

      ah…. I made a mistake there. I always had this thought that Neverwinter would be an MMO.

      So I suppose Cryptic’s Neverwinter and Runic’s Torchlight will have their own set of pros and cons, depending on whether they get released or not. I’m hoping both will be quality games, though. 🙂

  3. Hudson permalink
    June 1, 2011 12:03

    It will only end in disaster, Perfect World is one of the worst Asian free to play MMO’s I have ever suffered through. It will be a dismal end to Cryptic and a long death

    • June 1, 2011 12:29

      Don’t they have other releases that might be better than Perfect World?

    • June 2, 2011 00:26

      Ah…ignore Hudson…he is on a “All MMO’s will fail because of this…and this…and this” rant.

      For example, one rant was Rift download being on sale (not HARD copy) and the Free transfers just announced meant the end of Trion…LOL..

      DOOM…I say…DOOOOMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!!

  4. June 2, 2011 05:55

    In my opinion there is no real reason to think of this as a mess. Atari wanted to sell a company that was underperforming against their expectations, perfect world wants to make inroads into the western market.

    Atari bought cryptic while they had zero products on the market, perfect world bought them while they have 2 products that bring in revenue (and likely got to see the financial situation before buying) and therefore likely paid a not outrageous price for them.

    So where is the mess outside of the biased opinion that f2p games are ruining the lives of certain bloggers?

    • June 2, 2011 07:44

      I suppose the truth of the matter would be that it’s only a mess if Perfect World screws up their implementation of plans for STO, if they plan on ordering it around, that is. 🙂


  1. Insert Coin To Continue: Perfect World Buys Cryptic Studios | Vicarious Existence

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: